And I finally am on my first assignment for the video piracy class here at Umich!I finally embark on a journey to hunt down found footage and then using it to say what I'm trying to say!
I wasnt sure what I wanted to work on, but I knew it had to do with the media. Lately, my views on information gatekeeping by the media have been becoming more and more fierce. Media and news channels, that are one of the most fluent ways of getting information across are getting more and more influenced by different political parties and that's adversely affecting the kind of information that we, citizens, are receiving.
So after a decent amount of brainstorming, I narrowed down to the entire concept of re-making movies. :)
Why do we re-make movies? Is it because Bollywood is running out of ideas? Or is it because they're trying to preserve classic stories? Or maybe even trying to "educate" the next generation about a classic movie? And maybe the latter two are curtains to hide behind, so we don't have to admit to the former!
How do audiences change? What causes this change and what influences it to take the shape that it does? What effect does this change have on classical stories and the idea of re-makes??
There are so many re-makes- and different kinds of re-makes; bollywood re-makes of older bollywood stories, bollywood re-makes of hollywood movies, bollywood mash-ups of many hollywood movies, and director's takes on older movies.
Now there have been soooo many re-makes, there was far too much to choose from. So I came down to a classic novella, that's been re-made more than a few times. Devdas, was first made in 1928, and since then, has been re-made, 9 times! The tenth version of this movie, (well, it's not really a version, but Anurag Kashyap's take on the story- he's adapted it to be far quite modern), is Dev D., that scheduled to release this year!
What's really nice when we look at these 10 different versions of devdas,that span over 5 or so different languages (including Tamil, Asamese, Hindi, Telgu and Bengali- the original book was in bengali), is the treatment. One can clearly see how the (visual) idea of romance changes, how the sets change, how the delivery of dialogues and the choreography of dances have changed. More than to do with different people, I think it has alot to do with people, society and the way society thinks. The concept of rich and poor, of humiliation, love , sacrifice, promise, alcoholism, anger, dressing, fashion, hierarchy all changes with time, influenced by perception. And it's this perception and re-construction that follows that ignites the spark of curiosity. The older generation that has long loved Dilip Kumar as Devdas, PROBABLY would like to contrast Shahrukh Khan in the same role! And time, technology and audiences have certainly changed from the Dilip Kumar period to the King Khan's reign. And the questions that cause much debate remain- has the charm been maintained? Has the story been preserved well? Has justice been done?
Contributers at Wikipedia were nice enough to put out a list comprising of all the devdases that have ever been, and are to be in the very near future! Here goes:
•Devdas (1928 film), directed by Naresh Mitra, starring Phani Burma as Devdas, Tarakbala as Paro, and Niharbala/Miss Parul as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (1935 film), directed by P.C. Barua, starring himself as Devdas, Jamuna as Paro, and Chandrabati Devi as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (1936 film), directed by P.C. Barua, starring K.L. Saigal as Devdas, Jamuna as Paro, and Rajkumari as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (1937 film) (in Assamese), directed by P.C. Baruah, starring Phani Sharma as Devdas, Zubeida as Paro, and Mohini as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (1953 film) (also known as "Devadasu") (in Tamil and Telugu), directed by Vedantam Raghavaiah, starring Akkineni Nageswara Rao as Devdas, and Savitri as Paro.
•Devdas (1955 film), directed by Bimal Roy, starring Dilip Kumar as Devdas, Suchitra Sen as Paro, and Vyjayantimala as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (1979 film) (also known as "Debdas"), directed by Dilip Roy, starring Soumitra Chatterjee as Devdas, Sumitra Mukherjee as Paro, and Supriya Choudhury as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (2002 Bengali film), directed by Shakti Samanta, starring
Prasenjit Chatterjee as Devdas, Arpita Pal as Paro, and Indrani Halder as Chandramukhi.
•Devdas (2002 film), directed by Sanjay Leela Bhansali, starring Shahrukh Khan as Devdas, Aishwarya Rai as Paro, and Madhuri Dixit as Chandramukhi.
•Dev D (2009 film), directed by Anurag Kashyap, starring Abhay Deol as Dev, Mahi Gill as Paro, and Kalki as Chanda, Anurag Kashyap's version of Chandramukhi.
And along with this, I though I would put out a couple of you-tubers, that propped up in my research!
I'm not sure if this one is the telgu version of devdas, starring "superstar krishna"- can someone please confirm it for me??
And last but not the least, P.C. Barua's version, i think the 1936 one;